Choosing between Anthem and Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) can feel overwhelming, but understanding their differences helps you pick the right health insurance.
Both are major players in the U.S. health insurance market, offering plans for individuals, families, and employers. This article compares Anthem vs Blue Cross Blue Shield in terms of plans, costs, networks, and benefits using simple language.
Understanding Anthem and Blue Cross Blue Shield
Anthem is a single company operating under the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, serving 14 states like California, New York, and Indiana. BCBS is a federation of 34 independent companies, each covering specific regions, such as Florida Blue or CareFirst. Anthem vs Blue Cross Blue Shield often comes up because Anthem is a BCBS brand, but other BCBS companies operate differently.
Both provide access to the BlueCard program, allowing members to use in-network providers nationwide. Anthem focuses on integrated health solutions, while BCBS companies emphasize local care. Your choice depends on your location and needs.
Plan Types Offered
Both Anthem and BCBS offer similar plan types, but their specifics vary by region. Anthem operates as BCBS in its states, so its plans align with the BCBS framework. Here’s a look at the main plan types for both:
- Preferred Provider Organization (PPO): Offers flexibility to see any doctor, with lower costs for in-network providers.
- Health Maintenance Organization (HMO): Requires a primary care physician and referrals for specialists, often with lower premiums.
- Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO): Covers only in-network providers, except in emergencies, balancing cost and flexibility.
- High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP): Features lower premiums and higher deductibles, often paired with Health Savings Accounts (HSAs).
Anthem’s plans are consistent across its states, while BCBS plans vary by company. Check your local provider for specific options.
Network Size and Provider Access
Anthem vs Blue Cross Blue Shield differs significantly in network size due to their structures. Anthem boasts a network of over 1.7 million providers across its 14 states. BCBS, as a federation, collectively covers more providers nationwide, with each company maintaining its own network.
The BlueCard program ensures both Anthem and BCBS members can access care anywhere in the U.S. Anthem’s network is standardized, which is great for consistency. BCBS networks vary by region, so provider access depends on your local company.
Cost Comparison
Costs for Anthem and BCBS plans include premiums, deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. Anthem’s premiums for individuals range from $200 to $800 monthly, depending on the plan and state. BCBS premiums vary widely by company, typically falling in a similar range.
Deductibles for both can range from $500 to $8,000 annually. Anthem’s standardized pricing offers predictability, while BCBS costs depend on the regional company. Subsidies from the marketplace can lower costs for eligible members.
Cost Comparison Table
Here’s a table comparing estimated costs for a 30-year-old individual in a PPO plan:
| Provider | Monthly Premium | Deductible | Out-of-Pocket Max | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthem | $400–$700 | $1,000–$3,000 | $6,000–$9,000 | Consistent across 14 states |
| BCBS | $350–$750 | $800–$3,500 | $5,500–$9,000 | Varies by regional company |
Costs are approximate and depend on location and plan specifics. Check with Anthem or your local BCBS for exact pricing.
Prescription Drug Coverage
Both Anthem and BCBS include prescription drug coverage in most plans. Anthem uses a formulary managed by its pharmacy benefit manager, often IngenioRx, with copays of $10–$30 for generics and $40–$100 for brand-name drugs. BCBS formularies vary by company, but costs are similar.
In-network pharmacies like CVS or Walgreens keep costs low for both. Anthem offers mail-order services for maintenance drugs, as do many BCBS companies through partners like Prime Therapeutics. Non-covered drugs may require a medical necessity request.
Medicare and Federal Employee Plans
Anthem vs Blue Cross Blue Shield also differs in Medicare and federal employee offerings. Anthem provides Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Part D plans in its 14 states, with premiums from $0–$200 monthly. BCBS companies offer similar plans, but availability and costs vary by region.
For federal employees, both participate in the Federal Employees Health Benefits (FEHB) program. The Blue Cross and Blue Shield Service Benefit Plan, used by both, offers Standard and Basic options with premiums of $100–$300 biweekly. Anthem’s plans are uniform, while BCBS plans differ by company.
Member Benefits and Services
Anthem emphasizes integrated care through programs like Sydney Health, a digital platform for managing benefits. It offers wellness programs, telehealth, and 24/7 nurse hotlines. BCBS companies provide similar services, but their wellness programs and digital tools vary, like Florida Blue’s community centers or CareFirst’s health coaching.
Both cover preventive care, such as annual checkups and vaccinations, at no extra cost. Anthem’s standardized benefits are consistent, while BCBS benefits depend on the regional company. Both offer robust telehealth options for convenience.
Enrollment Process
Enrolling in Anthem or BCBS plans is straightforward. Anthem members sign up through Anthem’s website, the marketplace, or employers in its 14 states. BCBS enrollment varies by company, using local websites, the marketplace, or employers.
Open enrollment runs from November to January, with special enrollment for life events like marriage. You’ll need personal details like income and Social Security number. Federal employees enroll through the Office of Personnel Management (OPM).
Customer Support and Resources
Anthem provides support through its website, Sydney Health app, and customer service at 1-833-901-1364. The app helps manage claims, find providers, and access telehealth. BCBS support varies by company, with local phone numbers and apps like Horizon’s Blue app or Florida Blue’s portal.
Both offer 24/7 nurse hotlines and language assistance. Anthem’s support is centralized, while BCBS support depends on the regional company. Online cost estimators help plan expenses for both.
Community Health Initiatives
Anthem invests in community health through the Anthem Foundation, supporting programs for mental health and chronic disease management. BCBS companies, like Horizon BCBSNJ or Florida Blue, fund local initiatives tailored to their regions, such as wellness workshops or healthcare access programs.
Both aim to reduce long-term costs by promoting healthier communities. Anthem’s efforts are consistent across its states, while BCBS initiatives vary by company. Choosing either supports community health.
Tips for Choosing Between Anthem and BCBS
To decide between Anthem vs Blue Cross Blue Shield, consider these factors:
- Location: Anthem serves 14 states; BCBS covers all 50 through local companies.
- Network Needs: Check provider availability in your area using Anthem or BCBS tools.
- Plan Consistency: Anthem offers uniform plans; BCBS plans vary by region.
- Cost Preferences: Compare premiums and deductibles for your budget.
- Additional Services: Look at wellness programs and digital tools offered.
These steps help you pick the plan that best fits your needs.
Summary
The comparison of Anthem vs Blue Cross Blue Shield hinges on their structure and regional differences. Anthem, a BCBS company in 14 states, offers consistent plans and benefits, while BCBS’s 34 companies provide varied options by region.
Both offer PPO, HMO, EPO, and HDHP plans, large networks, and BlueCard access. By comparing costs, networks, and services, you can choose the best plan for your healthcare needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What plans do Anthem and BCBS offer?
Both offer PPO, HMO, EPO, and HDHP plans. Anthem’s plans are consistent across 14 states, while BCBS plans vary by regional company. Check local websites for details.
How do Anthem and BCBS networks compare?
Anthem has a network of 1.7 million providers in 14 states; BCBS’s network size varies by company but covers the U.S. Both use BlueCard for nationwide access. Verify local providers.
Are prescription drugs covered by both?
Yes, both include prescription coverage with copays of $10–$100 based on formularies. In-network pharmacies and mail-order services save money. Check your plan’s formulary.
Which is better for Medicare plans?
Anthem offers Medicare plans in 14 states; BCBS plans vary by region. Costs range from $0–$300 monthly. Compare local offerings for the best fit.
How do I contact Anthem or BCBS support?
Anthem’s support is at 1-833-901-1364 or via the Sydney Health app. BCBS support varies by company; check local websites or member cards for contact info.
Sources: